This was a big disappointment. I love goldfish, and have been a safe food for a long time. Goldfish has been one of the few foods that have stayed on my safe food list from the beginning. I was really excited to try these because I love Parmesan cheese and I was hoping I would like these. They are way too bitter and taste like a sharp cheese. These aren’t goldfish, I actually think they ruined the goldfish but changing their flavor. The texture is the same but the flavor isn’t good. I rate these