John Castic, 27, is the second 27-year-old man to be found dead in the Newtown Creek after attending a concert at a Brooklyn, N.Y., nightclub Sean Neumann is a reporter at PEOPLE. He has been ...

Two men, John Castic and Karl Clemente, both 27, were found dead in nearby Newtown Creek in separate incidents months apart. Another guest, Dr. Michael Bautista, was allegedly kidnapped after ...